Streamline Mortgages · FSRA Brokerage Licence #12750 · Serving homeowners across Ontario Apply OnlineCall 1-800-880-0068

Investing

First vs. Second Mortgage Investing: Yield and Risk Explained

Second mortgages pay more for a reason. Here's how mortgage position and loan-to-value change both your yield and the protection behind your money.

In short

  • First mortgages are repaid first – lower yield, more protection.
  • Second mortgages rank behind the first – higher yield, thinner protection.
  • Combined loan-to-value is the number that tells you how much equity stands between you and a loss.

When you invest in a private mortgage, two numbers shape almost everything: the position of your mortgage and the loan-to-value. Together they decide your yield – and how much risk you're taking for it.

What "position" means

Mortgages are repaid in the order they're registered. If a property is sold – voluntarily or through a power of sale – the first mortgage is paid out in full before the second sees anything.

  • First mortgage investors are first in line.
  • Second mortgage investors are paid only after the first lender, plus the costs of the sale.

That's why second mortgages carry higher rates.

The equity cushion

The equity cushion is the property value left over after all the mortgages ahead of and including yours. It's what protects your principal if the borrower defaults and the property is sold.

A worked example

Illustrative only. A property is worth $1,000,000.

First-mortgage investorSecond-mortgage investor
Mortgages ahead of youNone$550,000 first mortgage
Your loan$550,000$150,000
Loan-to-value at your position55%70% combined
Cushion below your loan45%30%
Illustrative yieldLower end of the 8–15% rangeHigher end of the range

If the property had to be sold for $800,000 after costs, the first-mortgage investor would be repaid in full. The second-mortgage investor would also be repaid – but with far less margin. At a lower sale price, the second investor would be the first to absorb a loss.

Which suits you?

You might prefer…If you…
First mortgagesPrioritize protecting capital and accept a lower yield
Second mortgagesWant higher income and are comfortable with more risk
A mix over timeWant to balance income and protection across several loans

What to check on any second mortgage

  • The first mortgage: balance, payment status, maturity date and lender.
  • Combined loan-to-value – many careful lenders stay at or below about 75%.
  • The borrower's exit – how both mortgages will be dealt with at maturity.
  • What happens if the first mortgage matures before yours.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Comparing yields without comparing LTV. A 13% second at 80% CLTV is very different from a 13% second at 60%.
  • Ignoring enforcement costs. Legal fees, arrears and time can consume part of the cushion.
  • Assuming the first lender will be patient. If the first mortgage goes into default, the second lender may need to act to protect its position.

Questions people ask

Are second mortgages a bad investment?

Not necessarily. They can be sound investments with a strong equity cushion and a credible exit – but they carry more risk than first mortgages, and the higher yield reflects that.

What loan-to-value is considered conservative?

It depends on the property and market, but many private lenders aim to stay at or below about 75% combined loan-to-value, and lower for unusual properties.

Can I see the first mortgage details before investing?

You should. Ask for the first mortgage balance, payment history and maturity date as part of your review.

Key takeaways

  • Position decides who gets paid first; loan-to-value decides how much cushion protects you.
  • Second mortgages pay more because they carry more risk.
  • Compare yield and combined LTV together – never yield alone.

Learn more: invest in private mortgages · what is a loan-to-value ratio · first vs. second mortgage

Questions about your situation?

Leave your details – I'll call you back, usually within one business day.

Principal Broker · FSRA #M12001646 · Credentials

Important: All mortgage financing is subject to lender approval, underwriting, property valuation, legal review and applicable regulatory requirements. Rates, fees and terms vary by lender and borrower and are not guaranteed. Information on this website is general and educational, and is not financial, legal or tax advice for your specific situation.

Call Apply Now