In short
- A HELOC is usually cheaper and more flexible – but you have to qualify with a bank.
- A second mortgage is easier to qualify for and funds a lump sum – but costs more.
- If you qualify for a HELOC, it usually wins. If you don't, a second mortgage can bridge the gap.
You have equity in your home and you need to use some of it. You don't want to break a low-rate first mortgage. That leaves two common options: a home equity line of credit (HELOC) or a second mortgage. They solve the same problem in very different ways.
How a HELOC works
A HELOC is a revolving line of credit secured by your home. You borrow what you need, repay it and borrow again – like a credit card, but at a much lower rate. Most HELOCs come from banks and credit unions and are priced at prime plus a margin.
Federally regulated lenders limit the revolving HELOC portion to 65% of your home's value, and the HELOC plus your mortgage to 80%. Because it comes from a bank, you need to pass bank qualifying rules – income, credit and the stress test.
How a second mortgage works
A second mortgage is a separate loan registered behind your first. You receive a lump sum and make regular payments – often interest-only. Second mortgages come mainly from private and alternative lenders, who focus on your equity and your exit plan more than your income or credit. See second mortgages in Ontario.
Side by side
| HELOC | Second mortgage | |
|---|---|---|
| Who offers it | Banks and credit unions | Mostly private and alternative lenders |
| Qualifying | Bank rules: income, credit, stress test | Equity and exit plan first |
| How you borrow | Draw and repay as needed | One lump sum |
| Rate | Usually prime plus a margin – lower | Higher |
| Fees | Often minimal | Lender, brokerage, appraisal and legal fees |
| Typical term | Open-ended | Usually 12 months or less (private) |
| Best for | Ongoing or uncertain costs | A defined need when the bank says no |
A worked example
Illustrative only. A homeowner with a $900,000 home and a $450,000 first mortgage needs $100,000.
- With a HELOC at an illustrative prime-plus rate around 6%, interest-only, the monthly cost is about $500 – with little or no setup cost. They need to qualify with the bank.
- With a private second mortgage at an illustrative 11%, interest-only, the monthly cost is about $917 – plus lender and brokerage fees. They don't need to pass bank income tests.
If the HELOC is available, it's clearly cheaper. The second mortgage earns its place when the bank won't approve the HELOC – because of income, credit or timing.
When a HELOC is the better choice
- You qualify with a bank and want the lowest cost.
- You need money over time – a renovation, tuition or business cash flow.
- You want to repay and reborrow without new paperwork.
When a second mortgage makes more sense
- Your bank declined the HELOC because of income documentation or credit.
- You need funds quickly – for arrears, CRA debt or a closing.
- You have a clear plan to repay within the term.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Treating a HELOC like free money. Interest-only HELOCs never pay themselves off unless you make extra payments.
- Ignoring fees on a short second mortgage. Fees spread over 12 months can add significantly to the effective cost.
- Forgetting the exit. A second mortgage needs a repayment plan from day one.
Questions people ask
Can I have both a HELOC and a second mortgage?
It's possible, but lenders look at combined loan-to-value. Many private lenders cap all borrowing at around 75% of the home's value.
Is HELOC interest tax-deductible?
Only in specific cases, such as borrowing to earn investment or business income. Ask your accountant before you rely on it.
Can I convert a second mortgage into a HELOC later?
Often, yes. Once your credit or income qualifies with a bank, refinancing the second mortgage into a bank HELOC or a single new mortgage is a common exit.
Key takeaways
- If you qualify for a HELOC, it's usually the lower-cost choice.
- A second mortgage trades higher cost for easier qualifying and speed.
- Compare the total dollar cost over the time you'll actually borrow.
Learn more: second mortgages in Ontario · first vs. second mortgage · mortgage refinancing
Questions about your situation?
Leave your details – I'll call you back, usually within one business day.
Principal Broker · FSRA #M12001646 · Credentials
Important: All mortgage financing is subject to lender approval, underwriting, property valuation, legal review and applicable regulatory requirements. Rates, fees and terms vary by lender and borrower and are not guaranteed. Information on this website is general and educational, and is not financial, legal or tax advice for your specific situation.