Streamline Mortgages · FSRA Brokerage Licence #12750 · Serving homeowners across Ontario Apply OnlineCall 1-800-880-0068

Private Lending

How Private Lenders Evaluate a Mortgage Deal

From the lender's side of the table: the four things every private lender weighs, and how to present your file so it gets a yes.

In short

  • Private lenders weigh property, equity, exit and story – in that order.
  • The exit strategy decides most deals.
  • A clean, honest file gets better terms, faster.

My team arranges private mortgage investments for investors, so we review deals the way a private lender does. Here's what actually decides a yes.

1. The property

  • Value – supported by an independent appraisal
  • Location – urban and suburban homes are easier to lend on than remote properties
  • Condition and type – a well-kept detached home is lower risk than a property needing major work
  • Marketability – how quickly it would sell if it had to

2. The equity

Loan-to-value across all mortgages is the lender's safety cushion. Lower LTV means more lenders, better rates and lower fees. Many private lenders stop around 65–80% depending on the property and position.

3. The exit

The most important question: how and when will this loan be repaid? Strong exits are specific and realistic:

Weaker exitStronger exit
"I'll refinance later""Two years of filed returns in April; B-lender refinance in May"
"I'll sell eventually""Listing in spring; comparable sales support the price"
"Money is coming""Business sale closing in six months, documented"

4. The story

Lenders want to understand what happened – a divorce, a business downturn, a health issue – and why it's now under control. A short, honest explanation beats a perfect-looking file with gaps.

What also matters

  • Property tax and insurance status
  • Any arrears, CRA balances or other registrations on title
  • Your ability to make the payments (or prepaid interest)

How to present a strong file

  • Lead with a clear, written exit plan
  • Provide a recent appraisal or comparable sales
  • Disclose everything up front – surprises kill deals
  • Have ID, mortgage statements, tax and insurance documents ready

A worked example: two similar files

Illustrative only.

File AFile B
PropertyDetached home in a strong suburbRural property with limited comparable sales
Combined LTV60%75%
Exit planRefinance after CRA debt is cleared – documents ready"We'll figure it out"
StoryClear explanation of a one-time setbackInconsistent information
Likely resultSeveral lenders interested, better termsFewer lenders, higher cost – or a decline

Same borrower profile, very different outcomes. Private lenders are pricing risk – the clearer and safer the file, the better the terms.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Hiding problems. Arrears, liens or past defaults will show up in the title search or credit report. Disclose them upfront.
  • Overstating value. An unrealistic value estimate wastes time once the appraisal comes in.
  • A vague exit. "I'll refinance" isn't a plan. Show what will change and when.

Questions people ask

Do private lenders check credit?

Most do, but credit is secondary to equity and the exit plan. They want to understand what happened and whether it's resolved.

What loan-to-value do private lenders allow?

Many cap combined loan-to-value at around 75%, sometimes lower for rural properties, condos in certain buildings or properties in poor condition.

Learn more: private mortgage lenders in Ontario · how private mortgages work · Thinking of lending? Invest in private mortgages

Questions about your situation?

Leave your details – I'll call you back, usually within one business day.

Principal Broker · FSRA #M12001646 · Credentials

Important: All mortgage financing is subject to lender approval, underwriting, property valuation, legal review and applicable regulatory requirements. Rates, fees and terms vary by lender and borrower and are not guaranteed. Information on this website is general and educational, and is not financial, legal or tax advice for your specific situation.

Call Apply Now